Observation essay peer review

Jorg Weingrill As we approach the end of the long academic year and my students prepare their first draft of their final paper for peer review, I thought it would be fitting to reflect on the pedagogical practice of peer reviews in a writing course. First off, let me say that my colleague in the Department of Rhetoric and Writing, Cate Blouke, convinced me last semester to make the switch to digital submissions of writing assignments.

Observation essay peer review

Jorg Weingrill As we approach the end of the long academic year and my students prepare their first draft of their final paper for peer review, I thought it would be fitting to reflect on the pedagogical practice of peer reviews in a writing course. First off, let me say that my colleague in the Department of Rhetoric and Writing, Cate Blouke, convinced me last semester to make the switch to digital submissions of writing assignments.

At times, students had difficulty sharing their papers via this tool, so I also made BlackBoard digital submissions an option.

Peer Reviews Work: Observations and Reflections | Blogging Pedagogy

Checking for student assignments in two different web-based software programs required a bit of extra work on my part, but because I believe in democratic, student-centered classroom practices, I was willing to provide options as we made the switch from paper to digital submissions.

This spring, consolidating all of my classroom instructions, resources, and student work into one place with the PBWorks wiki system was a breath of fresh air. At the beginning, a few students had a bit of anxiety about using the online workspace; none of them had used a wiki before.

And, as another student put it, "The wiki kinda grew on me.

Teaching Writing -- Peer Critique of Observation

I actually like this way of organization much better, because it is efficient and fast. I even have to make one final plug for digital submissions and contest a comment Ms. Blouke makes in her discussion of some of the pitfalls of digital submissions, "No system is entirely perfect.

Once papers are all on the wiki, I simply need to download them and create a folder devoted to comments on that particular writing assignment.

In fact, I plan on reading papers while in the air during my travels this weekend. At the start of the semester, I envisioned that students would provide comments on papers digitally—much like I do with their papers.

However, before the first review session, students were very vocal about having hard copies to work with as well. So, that has been our practice. And, as fellow bloggers Blouke and Jay Voss have pointed out, this preference is clearly an uncommon one.

So, in my class, I require both.

Sample Peer Review Sheets

Students ask for printed copies, and they get what they want for those peer reviews. I can check to see whether they completed a full first draft: Reviewers were unable to answer all the questions I set out for them to respond to when their partners only had a page or two of their paper completed.

Students can more easily include specific examples in their feedback: Since the peer review prompts students to be as specific as possible e.

Observation essay peer review

Increased sense of online collaboration and interaction: They are then able to type up a review and reflect on the paper copy and use the electronic copy as needed. The peer review process requires online collaboration because students usually do not finish their reviews during class time; they can use the wiki or BlackBoard to email their reviews to their partners.

I also ask that they post their reviews on the wiki so I may see what kind of responses they had. Last, for multimodal compositions, electronic submissions are the only kind that make sense.

And, since I use The Learning Record as my method of assessing student learning processes, I have the privilege of sharing evidence of the purposefulness and helpfulness of peer reviews from the students themselves.Peer Review: Writing to Make an Observation.

Directions: Please respond to the following questions in as much detail as possible. Pick a bright color for your responses so they stand out from the questions.

Observing And Giving Constructive Feedback. Print or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of UK Essays.

a discussion about designing and developing research projects within the training scheme and was an opportunity for a peer discussion/review of a proposed . Essay #2: Observation The observation essay is “an essay that draws on the writer’s observations of people, places, and/or events to support the writer’s claims about what these observations mean.”.

Search form

Official Web site of the University Writing Program, Brandeis Univ., Waltham, Mass. A Breakdown of UWS Essay Types. Designing Complex Arguments. Sample Rubrics. Sample Peer Review Sheets. Click on a Peer Review sheet to download. All sheets are Word documents.

General. Frequently required in college writing classes, observation papers are a great way for any writer to hone his skills. Not only does an observation paper require you to .

methods of peer review. (p. 4) The Case for Peer Classroom Observations atic peer observation program that has been in place at The University of Maryland University College since the mid's (for a further description. To Improve the Academy of the program, see Millis, ).

Consistent with the process established in.

The Example of Observation Report | amah - attheheels.com